(International-199) Feb 9, 2019 – Open Prisons in India, why not USA? Overcrowding a crisis in American prisons!


PERSONAL NOTE: What a brilliant idea…open prisons…if it works in India, it should work anywhere in the world. American taxpayers are funding the housing of many people in overcrowded jails in USA…open prisons would be a way to solve overcrowding, but more importantly giving prisoners a sense of worth and self-esteem that you are still useful to the society…someone in USA should study this idea from India…of course, if you do not behave, you go back to the prisons, the real prisons…what an incentive to do good and to improve your lives outside the gates of real prisons!  Peace, steve, usa, feb 9, 2019   stephenehling@hotmail.com   blog – https://getting2knowyou-china.com


A prison where the inmates have to go and find jobs
• 4 February 2019 BBC NEWS

At Sanganer prison, in the Indian city of Jaipur, inmates get a roof over their head, but no money and no food. This means they must go to work and earn their living beyond the prison gates, writes Masuma Ahuja – as labourers, factory workers, drivers, even yoga teachers.
Ramchand drives a school bus. His wife, Sugna, works at a garment factory. On a recent hot afternoon, I drink a cup of tea with them in their one-room house, which has yellow walls and a corrugated metal roof, a fridge and a TV, a lunchbox hanging in the corner next to photos of gods and a stack of newspapers. From their door, you can see cars zooming by on a nearby highway and beyond that, a skyline of modern high-rises.
This is how they tell their story: he was lonely, her family had left her. Their neighbours wanted to set them up and arrange their marriage, so she wouldn’t be a woman living alone, so he would have someone to take care of him, cook for him and make him rotis. “I can make my own rotis,” he says. He married her because he fell for her.

There’s seemingly little out of the ordinary about their house, or their story. Except that Ramchand and Sugna are both convicted murderers and they live in prison.
Their house is in Sanganer Open Prison, in Jaipur, the capital city of India’s western state of Rajasthan. This prison has no bars or walls, no security guards at the gate, and prisoners are allowed – even encouraged – to go out into the city and work every day. This prison, which has been open since the 1950s, is home to 450 prisoners and is one of about 30 such institutions in the state of Rajasthan.
 From Our Own Correspondent has insight and analysis from BBC journalists, correspondents and writers from around the world
 Listen on iPlayer, get the podcast or listen on the BBC World Service, or on Radio 4 on Saturdays at 11:30 BST
I go to Sanganer with Smita Chakraburtty, the woman behind a campaign to make open prisons the norm across India. She has made the case to India’s Supreme Court, which in turn has asked states to look into setting up more places like this. She now serves as an honorary commissioner of prisons in Rajasthan, and was recently shortlisted for India’s Agami Prize for her work on the penal system.
Image captionSmita Chakraburtty with Sugna (right) and another prisoner
“The criminal justice system addresses an incident… and doesn’t know what to do with an individual,” Chakraburtty argues. Her cause is gaining momentum: four other states in India established new open prisons last year. When I visit Sanganer with Smita, she gives prisoners the latest updates on her work, and then they swarm to me, eager to chat. While there are no guards and anyone can enter the prison, visitors like me are rare.
I sit on the floor in a children’s nursery at the front of the prison grounds and talk with a group of men and women who are inmates. When I ask them why they’re in prison, many simply say, “302,” referring to Section 302 in India’s Penal Code which dictates the punishment for murder. They call the open prison “the farm,” and gush about how easy it is to live here, how happy they are.
dwellings, and beyond them a residential area
To get to Sanganer, they all have to have served at least two-thirds of their sentences in closed prisons, and they say that compared to those places, this is freedom. In fact, the government in Rajasthan has had to evict prisoners who didn’t want to leave. They had set up lives – stable jobs, schools for their children – in this neighbourhood, that they didn’t want to give up at the end of their sentences.
Still, many prisoners tell me they struggle with outsiders’ perception of prison. Some women inmates say it’s easier to marry a man on the inside, because men outside prison don’t understand their experiences. Even getting a job can be hard for some inmates, they say people are hesitant to hire them once they present their prison IDs.
Open prisons in India
 At the end of 2015, out of a total of 419,623 prisoners in India, 3,789 (0.9%) were held in open prisons
 Two states, Rajasthan and Maharashtra had 42 open prisons – more than half of the total
 Twenty-one open prisons were distributed among 15 other states
Source: Prison Statistics India 2015
But they still live a version of a normal life here: they buy motorcycles, smartphones, and televisions; they wear no prison uniform and live in small numbered houses. Each prisoner is allotted a government-provided house along one of Sanganer’s narrow lanes. The rest is up to them. The prison doesn’t provide them with any food, water or income.
prisoners must attend an evening roll call
So every day, most of them leave the prison grounds to earn a living: men convicted of murder work as security guards, factory workers and daily labourers. I even meet one inmate who’s a yoga instructor and another who’s a supervisor in a nearby school.
The only real rule, I’m told, is that prisoners must make roll call every evening. Sanganer hardly seems like a prison, except at this moment. At sundown, representatives of the prison’s elected governing body stand at the prison entrance. An inmate with a microphone begins taking attendance, calling out numbers from 1 to 450. Sometimes, he stops at a number and scolds a prisoner for leaving rubbish outside his or her house.
Everyone must be accounted for… or risk return to a closed prison.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s